Pie and Mash vs Salmon and Salad

Tonights dinner.
The Boys: Pie and Mash

Plate: 1 Steak pie, mash potato, peas and sweetcorn, gravy.
Total calories: 1250
Yum Factor: he loved it

Mine: Large Salad with Baked Salmon

Plate: lettuce,  watercress, rocket, baby spinach,  celery, spring onion, cheey tomatoes, sweetcorn, salmon, chilli, lime
Calories: 365
Yum factor: blooming lush.

Which looks looks yummiest?
Which would you rather eat?